Spokane Journal of Business

Guest Commentary: Forest health practices should include logging, planting


  • Print Article

Washington’s Board of Natural Resources is considering banning timber harvesting on state lands. That is extremely unwise. Instead, the board must ensure its healthy forest policies incorporate all management tools, including planting, thinning, and logging.

The board, established in 1957, sets policies to manage Washington’s 5.6 million acres granted by Congress in 1889. More than 3 million acres were designated as trust lands to support various public institutions. Of that trust land, 2.1 million acres are forests.

Banning timber harvesting robs critical funds from K-12 public schools, timber-dependent communities, the universities of Washington and Washington State, the state capitol building, and public agencies, such as law enforcement and social services.

In contrast to generating timber sales revenues, fighting wildfires cost our state millions and drains our state’s emergency reserves. Those wildfires are fueled by the build-up of dead, downed, and diseased trees and ground debris in unhealthy forests.

Healthy forests are important in capturing CO2.

“Our forests are our friends in terms of limiting atmospheric carbon dioxide,” says Matthew Ayres, a professor of biological science at Dartmouth. His research shows that forests can provide sustainable products such as lumber, pulp, and fuel while still serving as reservoirs for lots of carbon, depending on how forests are managed.

Hotter, drier summers and longer fire seasons—combined with unhealthy forests—have led to increases in fire starts and areas burned, according to the state’s Department of Natural Resources. Fires in 2014 and 2015 burned nearly 1.5 million acres of public and private forestlands and cost more than $500 million to suppress.

At the federal level, costs of fighting fires jumped last year to 55% of the U.S. Forest Service budget, from 16% in 1995.

So, it is time to revisit the way we are overseeing our forests.

John Bailey, a professor of forest management at Oregon State University, believes “part of the solution is thinning forests through logging, prescribed burns, and allowing naturally occurring fires to be managed instead of extinguished.”

Cutting diseased, dead, and fire-damaged trees is not new. In intermountain forests, loggers once salvaged beetle-killed trees and sent them to rural sawmills to be cut into two-by-fours. That practice was severely curtailed 30 years ago.

Knowing that mature trees are most susceptible to insects and disease, public forest managers once designed timber sales on small tracts as fire breaks. The logging and subsequent cleanup removed forest fuels which, in recent years, have been allowed to accumulate.

Harvesting helped fund replanting and fire access road construction. Environmental mitigation techniques have dramatically improved, resulting in clean water, healthier air quality, and unencumbered access for fish returning to spawning grounds.

As we look forward to more austere times, we must revise management practices in state and federal forests. We can no longer allow nature to just take its course. There needs to be a more balanced approach which reduces the risk of wildfire.

Megafires are polluting our air, endangering our health and safety, and burning a bigger hole in our pocketbooks. By thinning, salvaging, and logging, we could not only save expenses, but create jobs and bring in needed revenue to the government.

Don C. Brunell is a business analyst, writer, and retired president of the Association of Washington Business. He now lives in Vancouver, Washington, and can be contacted at theBrunells@msn.com.

Like this story?

You’ll love the rest. Subscribe today, and you’ll receive a year’s subscription to the Journal of Business, unlimited access to this website, daily business news emails, and weekly industry-specific
e-newsletters. Click here for 50% off your first year.

  • Don Brunell

  • Follow RSS feed for Don Brunell

Read More

Sign up for our E-mail updates

including the
Morning Edition

Join our list