
Keri Spanier, CPFA, founder of Liberty Lake-based LibertyRoad Advisors, has more than 25 years of experience, specializing in helping employers navigate fiduciary responsibilities, evaluate plan fees, and improve retirement outcomes for employees. She can be reached at [email protected] or through www.libertyroadadvisors.com.
| Keri SpanierEvery Christmas, I get a card from a former plan participant. Years ago, she was an employee at a company whose retirement plan I advise. She was single, had an adult son living at home, and was getting ready to retire with a modest nest egg she'd spent her working life building. The problem? The stock market wasn't exactly cooperating.
There was a lot of volatility, and understandably, she was nervous. She didn't have millions of dollars or a team of financial professionals helping her figure things out. She had her 401(k), and she needed it to last.
Fortunately, I had helped her employer add a retirement income solution to the 401(k) plan that allowed her to convert her savings into guaranteed monthly income for life. We talked through her options and decided it was the right fit for her situation. Not long afterward, the market took a significant dive, and my phone rang. She was so relieved — so thankful — that what was happening in the markets wasn't going to change her ability to pay her bills that month or the next. She wasn't calling because she'd beaten the market. She was calling because she didn't have to worry about it anymore.
That phone call has stayed with me, and so have the Christmas cards that arrive in my mailbox every year, without fail.
Beyond industry hype
Which brings me to the latest trends in retirement planning. I've spent much of my career advising retirement plans in the San Francisco Bay Area, and more recently in the Spokane-Coeur d'Alene region. It's given me an interesting perspective on how our industry is evolving.
And believe me, we love a new idea. Private investments in 401(k) plans? Let's talk about them. Expanded Roth opportunities? Absolutely. Artificial intelligence, personalized investment strategies, new retirement income solutions? There's plenty to be excited about. Some of these innovations are already finding their way into conversations with larger employers, while others are still being debated across the industry.
I'm genuinely excited about many of them. After more than 25 years in this business, I still love seeing what is coming next. But I also find myself wondering whether we're getting so good at improving retirement plans that we're forgetting to improve retirement for the participants in these plans. Sometimes the biggest opportunities aren't particularly glamorous.
True cost of plan fees
Take fiduciary responsibility and plan fees. I realize those words aren't going to make anyone the most popular person at a cocktail party — trust me, I've tried — but they matter a lot.
Consider a company with a $20 million 401(k) plan paying 0.25% annually in asset-based fees. That's $50,000 a year. Now imagine the markets have been kind and that plan grows to $30 million. The same percentage now costs $75,000 annually. That's an additional $25,000 a year, without necessarily receiving an additional $25,000 in services.
Does that automatically mean the fees are unreasonable? Of course not. But shouldn't somebody be asking the question? As retirement plans grow, employers have opportunities to revisit pricing, evaluate services, and make sure their fiduciary processes are keeping pace. That's not a particularly new trend, but it's an important one, especially for growing businesses.
The forgotten participant
And then there's the part I think deserves even more attention: the employees themselves.
Imagine two employees working for the same company. One has accumulated $1.2 million in retirement savings, works with a financial adviser, and is thinking about tax strategies and retirement income. The other has $38,000 saved, hasn't increased her contribution in years, and isn't sure she'll ever be able to retire. Both deserve a great retirement plan, but which one might benefit more from a little personal attention?
Our industry has developed some incredibly sophisticated tools for helping people manage wealth. But what about the employees who are still trying to build it? What about the person who doesn't understand the company match? Or the employee who has never considered increasing contributions by 1%? Or someone approaching retirement who simply needs help understanding the options available to them?
Sometimes nobody has ever taken the time to sit down and explain these things in a meaningful way. That's an opportunity for employers and retirement plan advisers to make a real difference.
Focus on the fundamentals
So, what should businesses in our region be paying attention to?
Yes, keep an eye on the innovations and trends. Retirement income solutions, Roth features, personalized advice, and new investment options may all have a place in the retirement plans of tomorrow. But we shouldn't overlook the fundamentals:
A retirement plan can have an impressive investment lineup, competitive fees, excellent fiduciary documentation, and all the latest features, but if employees aren't making progress toward retirement, we still have work to do.
Somewhere, there's another participant getting ready to retire. She doesn't need the fanciest investment strategy in the room; she needs someone to understand her situation, explain her options, and help her make a decision she can live with. If we can do more of that, I'd call it progress. And if a few more Christmas cards show up in my mailbox along the way? Even better.
Keri Spanier, CPFA, founder of Liberty Lake-based LibertyRoad Advisors, has more than 25 years of experience, specializing in helping employers navigate fiduciary responsibilities, evaluate plan fees, and improve retirement outcomes for employees. She can be reached at [email protected] or through www.libertyroadadvisors.com.
Subscribe to our newsletters and get the latest news and insights delivered to your inbox.
We respect your privacy.
Unsubscribe anytime.
You’re subscribed. Keep an eye on your inbox for the latest updates.
Your subscription will expire in less than 30 days. To ensure you do not lose access to any content, please renew your subscription now.
If you need help, please contact Jennifer Zurlini at [email protected], or (509) 344-1280.